fbpx
ranking liverpool managers premier league

Ranking all of Liverpool’s managers in the Premier League era

Jurgen Klopp recently celebrated four years in charge of Liverpool, with few managers having enjoyed such popularity at Anfield as the charismatic German.

The former Borussia Dortmund boss became the eighth man to take charge of the Merseyside outfit in the Premier League era, and whilst all have so far failed to end the club’s long wait for an elusive league title, each have enjoyed varying degrees of success.

We’ve decided to look back at the eight men to have sat in the Anfield dugout, ranking all of Liverpool’s managers in the Premier League era…

Graeme Souness

The story of a fallen former hero, Souness would return to Liverpool as manager following Kenny Dalglish’s shock resignation just before the dawn of the Premier League in 1991.

The club’s former captain had enjoyed an impressive beginning to his managerial career, winning three league titles at Rangers, but his spell in charge at Anfield is remembered for being the end of the club’s dominance of English football.

Critics of Souness often point to his attempt to change too much too quickly, as he ushered seven players out of the door in his first year in charge. However, Liverpool were in need of a rebuild, it’s just Souness got it all wrong.

The likes of Peter Beardsley and the promising Steve Staunton were amongst those allowed to depart, replaced by players who were not up to the level required. Poor recruitment and a lack of essential management qualities ultimately resulted in Liverpool’s rapid decline, perhaps the only positive of Souness’ reign his blooding of academy youngsters such as Robbie Fowler, Steve McManaman, Jamie Redknapp and Rob Jones.

Ranking: 2/10

Embed from Getty Images

Roy Evans

Likeable and a Liverpool man through and through, Roy Evans turned his hand to coaching on the recommendation of the great Bill Shankly and began his ascent through the ranks to the top job.

Having coached under Shankly, Bob Paisley, Joe Fagan, Kenny Dalglish and Souness, Evans would be appointed as the club’s new manager following the latter’s resignation in 1994.

With young starlets such as Fowler and McManaman flourishing alongside established names Ian Rush and John Barnes, Liverpool would win the League Cup in 1995 before losing the FA Cup final the following year.

Despite signing Stan Collymore in a British transfer-record deal and overseeing the emergence of a young Michael Owen, Evans was unable to take the club to the next level despite finishing in the division’s top four in each of his seasons at the club.

With Liverpool struggling to make the step-up, Gerard Houllier was appointed alongside Evans in a bizarre joint-managerial role rarely seen at the top level, before Evans later resigned to leave the Frenchman in sole charge.

Ranking: 4/10

Embed from Getty Images

Gerard Houllier

The popular Frenchman who sparked optimism that Liverpool could return to the elite, Houllier’s exciting young side at the turn of the millennium is one of the most memorable Reds teams from the Premier League era.

Liverpool would steadily progress in each of Houllier’s first three seasons, finishing fourth, third and then second as hopes raised of securing a first Premier League title. Whilst that would never come to fruition, the second of those seasons will live long in the memory for Liverpool supporters.

Houllier would guide the side to a remarkable treble of cup triumphs, his side inspired by the goals of Michael Owen and an emerging Steven Gerrard securing FA Cup, League Cup and UEFA Cup success in 2000/01.

The downfall of Houllier’s reign came in the summer of 2002, when after finishing runners-up the previous season, Liverpool would get their transfer activity spectacularly wrong as they attempted to go one better.

The decision to sign El-Hadji Diouf over the on-loan Nicolas Anelka looks even more wildly bizarre in hindsight, whilst the likes of Salif Diao and Bruno Cheyrou endured entirely forgettable Anfield careers.

Those mistakes would see Liverpool start to go backwards once more, finishing fifth and fourth in each of the next two seasons before the hierarchy once again decided on change.

Ranking: 6/10

Embed from Getty Images

Rafael Benitez

Replacing Houllier came an innovative Spanish coach, Rafael Benitez arriving from Valencia after a spell which saw him win two La Liga titles and the UEFA Cup.

Benitez’s start to life at Liverpool was made more difficult by Michael Owen’s summer departure to Real Madrid, though the additions of compatriots Xabi Alonso and Luis Garcia proved inspired.

Whilst he struggled to make much of an impact in the Premier League in his debut season, Benitez would instead deliver one of the club’s most memorable European campaigns. Rank underdogs, Liverpool would march through to a first European Cup final in 30 years.

That final would be one of the greatest in the competition’s history, Benitez’s side coming from three goals down at half-time to beat AC Milan on penalties in Istanbul, cementing his place in Liverpool history.

During his six seasons at the club Benitez would add FA Cup and UEFA Super Cup success, establishing Liverpool as a leading side in European competition by reaching a second Champions League final in 2007 and a semi-final the following year.

Bolstered by signings including Javier Mascherano and Fernando Torres, Liverpool would come close to winning the title in 2009, once again finishing runners-up. That would prove to be the beginning of the end for Benitez, however, as problems with the club’s ownership and loss of key players saw the Reds slump to a seventh-placed finish the following season.

Ranking: 7.5/10

Embed from Getty Images

Roy Hodgson

The worst appointment in Liverpool’s managerial history?

Rewind back to 2010 and it was dark times for Liverpool football club. American duo Tom Hicks and George Gillett had taken the club to the brink of administration, a series of broken promises, poor decisions and failed gambles leaving one of English football’s great clubs on the verge of ruin.

Their appointment of Fulham manager Roy Hodgson further set the club back, the veteran coach having endured a nomadic career without success at the very highest level.

Hodgson’s first summer saw him recruit the likes of Milan Jovanovic, Christian Poulsen and Paul Konchesky, each of whom showed no signs of being at the standard required.

He would further antagonise his own support with a series of ludicrous soundbites that would come to be known as ‘Royisms’, including describing a 2-0 derby defeat as the club’s finest performance of the season and refusing to rule out selling star forward Torres to arch-rivals Manchester United.

Unsurprisingly he lasted just half a season, sacked in January 2011 with few sad to see him go.

Ranking: 1/10

Embed from Getty Images

Kenny Dalglish

The return of the ‘King’ as he’s known amongst Liverpool fans, the ever-popular former player and manager returned to help revive the mess the club’s hierarchy had created.

Like many of his predecessors, his recruitment was a mixed bag, Dalglish’s first window in charge saw the arrival of Luis Suarez, though that move came in addition to the then club-record £35m transfer of Andy Carroll as Fernando Torres left for Chelsea.

He would lead Liverpool to both domestic cup finals in his first months in charge, winning one and losing the other, though the club continued to struggle in the Premier League.

He was dismissed at the end of the 2011/12 season, having overseen a difficult period for the club and ending a six-year wait for a major trophy.

Ranking: 4.5/1o

Embed from Getty Images

Brendan Rodgers

Dalglish’s departure saw the arrival of a young coach with a seemingly fresh approach, as Brendan Rodgers made the step up to one of English football’s biggest clubs after a successful period at Swansea City.

Rodgers arrival would see an entertaining brand of football return to Merseyside, though the young manager often showed naive tendencies during his time in the Anfield dugout. After a seventh-placed finish in his first season, the Northern Irishman would come as close to anyone to ending the club’s title drought, as a Luis Suarez-inspired side finished runners-up in 2013/14.

The campaign would prove one of the most entertaining in Premier League history, Liverpool’s strike partnership of Suarez and Daniel Sturridge finishing as the division’s top two scorers, ably supported by the likes of Steven Gerrard and Raheem Sterling.

However, the club’s swashbuckling style and 101 league goals would not be enough to deliver the ultimate success, narrowly pipped to the title by Manchester City following Gerrard’s now infamous slip against Chelsea.

Suarez’s subsequent departure and the poor investment of his £75m fee set Liverpool back once more, Rodgers sacked in 2015 after a sixth-placed finish the following year.

A talented manager who perhaps took the job too soon, Rodgers recruitment was also a major factor to his undoing as Liverpool boss.

Ranking: 5.5/10

Embed from Getty Images

Jurgen Klopp

The current occupant of the Liverpool hotseat, the popular German has transformed Liverpool from nearly men into one of Europe’s finest sides.

His tenure may have began slowly as he adjusted to life at the club, but Liverpool have undoubtedly showed sustained and significant progression in each of Klopp’s seasons in charge.

Having suffered agonising defeats in the League Cup, Europa League and Champions League finals, Klopp would deliver his first piece of silverware last season as Liverpool returned to the Champions League final for a second successive year, beating Tottenham in June’s showpiece event to be crowned champions of Europe for the sixth time.

Whilst one trophy – albeit a huge one – may not seem the greatest total for four years in charge, Klopp has helped transform the culture of the club and turned Liverpool into a destination club for Europe’s top talents.

Working alongside sporting director Michael Edwards and a series of specialist coaches, the club’s staff have got little wrong in the transfer market in recent seasons and look equipped for a period of sustained success.

Klopp’s side missed out on the title last season despite earning a club-record 97 points, and having begun the new campaign with eight successive wins, will hope this will be the year the club end their long wait for championship glory.

Should Klopp achieve it, he may just receive full marks.

Ranking: 9/10

Embed from Getty Images

Read: Five Jurgen Klopp signings that have transformed Liverpool

Read Also: The underperforming Premier League XI of the season so far