Ranking the eight best centre-backs in Premier League history

Successful teams are built from the back and every title-winning team requires a centre-back, or two, capable of shutting down the Premier League’s best forwards.

English football has been blessed with an abundance of brilliant centre-backs throughout the Premier League era, from lion-hearted leaders to classy central defenders with cool and composure.

We’ve attempted to whittle down the very best to have played in the Premier League, a difficult task when looking at the names who have just missed the cut. Here are our rankings of the eight best centre-backs in Premier League history.

8. Vincent Kompany

Vincent Kompany could not have envisaged such success when unveiled as Manchester City’s latest signing in 2008. An emerging midfielder during his time at Hamburg, he later settled at the heart of the defence for City and spent more than a decade as the club’s defensive leader.

City’s transformative takeover took place just days after Kompany’s arrival, but rather than be forced out following an influx of cash and new talent, the Belgian became a figurehead for the new era. He formed part of the side that ended a 35-year wait for major silverware with FA Cup success in 2011, before captaining the side to a first Premier League title the following season.

Kompany spent eight seasons as club captain at the Etihad, during the most successful era in City’s history. He added three further league titles and a host of domestic cup triumphs, while he developed a welcome knack of scoring important goals. His winner against Manchester United handed the title initiative to City in 2011/12, while his stunning effort against Leicester ensured Pep Guardiola’s side pipped Liverpool to the title in 2018/19

In total he made 338 appearances for the Citizens, with perhaps only his fitness issues preventing the Belgian from ranking higher here. He departed City as one of the club’s all-time greats, a player who just got what it meant to be a blue.

7. Jaap Stam

It’s not often that Sir Alex Ferguson’s judgement is wrong, but the Manchester United manager admits he got it wrong when allowing Jaap Stam to leave Old Trafford.

Stam had been a domineering presence in the Premier League’s best side, emerging as the division’s most intimidating defender after arriving from PSV Eindhoven. Deceptively quick, strong as an ox and with the shaven head and steely-stare of a nightclub doorman, Stam struck fear into opposition attackers.

His first season with the Red Devils saw Ferguson’s side conquer all, claiming a historic Premier League, Champions League and FA Cup treble. No English side – before or since – has matched that feat.

Embed from Getty Images

Stam added consecutive titles in each of the next two seasons and on each occasion was included in the PFA Team of the Year. The Dutchman was formidable and thriving, but his career with the club was cut short.

Ferguson felt that Stam had lost a yard of pace after an Achilles issue (alongside some controversial revelations about his manager in his autobiography) and a record offer from Lazio was accepted for his services. Stam went on to spend a further five seasons at the top level in Italy, while United relinquished their hold on the title to Arsenal the following season.

“When I think of disappointments, obviously Jaap Stam was always a disappointment to me, I made a bad decision there,” Ferguson later told MUTV.

Defensive Rocks: Jip Jaap Stam, a big Dutchman

6. Sol Campbell

There were few more intimidating sights for Premier League forwards than the presence of Sol Campbell bearing down on them.

Campbell came through the ranks at Tottenham, won major trophies on either side of the north London divide and later lifted an FA Cup at Portsmouth for good measure. A colossal centre-back presence with Herculean strength, he established himself as one of the division’s best at Spurs and captained the side to League Cup success in 1999.

An otherwise absence of silverware persuaded Campbell to move on, with the defender turning down interest from Europe’s elite to sign for the old enemy down the road.

His free transfer move to Arsenal remains arguably the most controversial deal in Premier League history, but one which saw both player and club thrive. At Arsenal, Campbell won a domestic double during his debut season, starred during the club’s ‘Invincibles’ campaign and scored in a Champions League final.

That latter title was won at White Hart Lane, as Campbell celebrated his second championship at the home of his former side. He made 111 appearances for the Gunners and later returned for a short second spell, having formed part of the Portsmouth side that won the FA Cup for the first time in 69 years under Harry Redknapp in 2008.

Defensive Rocks: Sol Campbell – The immovable Invincible

5. Virgil van Dijk

Virgil van Dijk is the sole inclusion on this list still in the midst of his career, but his achievements to date have placed the Dutchman in the conversation of great Premier League centre-backs.

After starring at Southampton following a move south from Celtic, he signed for Liverpool in a £75m deal in January 2018. That transfer was the most expensive fee ever paid for a defender at that time, but has proven fine business for the Reds.

Van Dijk had a transformative impact on Jurgen Klopp’s side, who turned from nearly-men to genuine contenders almost instantaneously. Van Dijk’s first full season saw Liverpool crowned as champions of Europe, with the defender named as the PFA Player’s Player of the Year and Premier League Player of the Season.

He became just the third defender to win the former award in the Premier League era and followed that individual accolade by featuring in every single minute of Liverpool’s 2019/20 title-winning season. That success ended a 30-year wait for a top-flight crown at Anfield, while he has also won the FA Cup, League Cup, Club World Cup, UEFA Super Cup and Community Shield in a clean sweep of honours.

Van Dijk’s peak seasons might not have the longevity of others on this list, but his absolute best level stacks up with any of the division’s greats.

4. Nemanja Vidic

“He come’s from Serbia, He’ll f****** murder ye!”

Nemanja Vidic might not have caused the actual fatalities regularly sang about at Old Trafford, but in footballing terms he certainly drained the life out of frustrated Premier League forwards. A rock at the back for the Red Devils, Vidic would thunder into challenges, bulldoze strikers, and throw his head into areas where others would wince just watching.

He proved the perfect tonic in partnership with Rio Ferdinand, the Eastern European grit to the latter’s guile and the foundation on which Sir Alex Ferguson’s last great side was built.

Vidic won five league titles and the Champions League with the club, while he is one of just four players – and the only defender – to win the Premier League Player of the Season award twice, alongside Thierry Henry, Kevin De Bruyne and Cristiano Ronaldo.

Iconic Duos: The Tank and The Rolls Royce, Vidic and Ferdinand

3. Tony Adams

Tony Adams remains the only man to have captained a title-winning team in three different decades, following an unforgettable one-club career at Arsenal.

Adams emerged pre-Premier League era and lifted the top-flight title in 1989 and 1991, before bridging the gap between old and new in the increasingly cosmopolitan and rebranded league.

The centre-back was the figurehead of Arsenal’s famous back five, one often still held up as the benchmark for defensive nous and unbreakable organisation. Adams was impeccable in his anticipation and timing, dominant in the air and willing to engage in any battle, the quintessential leader of Arsenal’s trophy-winning sides under George Graham and Arsene Wenger.

He battled off-the-pitch issues to win two Premier League titles under the latter, as Wenger forged the resilient rearguard of the previous era with his exciting continental imports. It was a recipe for success, as Arsenal swept to two domestic doubles in five seasons with Adams calling time on his career after their 2001/02 triumph.

He retired as Mr Arsenal, the club’s most successful captain and second-highest appearance maker with 669 outings for the club. He gave his utmost to win in each and every one of them.

2. John Terry

John Terry came through the academy ranks at Chelsea and departed two decades later as arguably the greatest player in the club’s history.

Terry was the pillar on which Chelsea’s modern success was built, the homegrown hero at the heart of the defence. He won every available major honour during his time at Stamford Bridge, lifting five Premier League titles, five FA Cups, three League Cups, the Champions League and Europa League.

The first of those league titles saw Terry named as the PFA Player of the Year, following a season in which Chelsea conceded an all-time record low of just 15 goals from their 38 games.

No defender in Premier League history has more clean sheets and no defender has scored more Premier League goals. Brave, commanding, and under-rated on the ball with excellent distribution off either foot, Terry was a defensive rock in west London.

Captain. Leader. Legend.

Iconic Duos: Chelsea’s impregnable pairing made of steel and silk, Terry and Carvalho

1. Rio Ferdinand

Rio Ferdinand earns our number one position, a defender who quite literally could do it all.

The term Rolls Royce is perhaps overused when describing defenders, but for Ferdinand it is a tag which has aptly stuck. Ferdinand would cruise through games with effortless grace, his kit free of mud and stains as he glided around robbing forwards of possession.

Twice he broke the British transfer record, after moves from West Ham to Leeds and from Elland Road to Manchester United. He won six league titles during his career with the latter, while he captained the side during their 2008 Champions League triumph in Moscow.

Ferdinand was a nightmare for Premier League forwards. Faster than them. Stronger than them. And, often, better on the ball than them. The game’s best defenders are rarely last-ditch or look in trouble. Few were one step ahead more often than Ferdinand.

Read – Defensive Rocks: Rio ‘Rolls-Royce’ Ferdinand

Read Also – Ranking the 8 best right-backs in Premier League history

Subscribe to our social channels:

Facebook | Instagram | Twitter | YouTube

Notify of

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
9 months ago

No Paul McGrath, what crap is this

The truth
The truth
7 months ago

whoever put VVD in this top 10 list, should be fired