pep guardiola manchester city premier league

Guardiola accused of 'overthinking' tactics following defeat to Man Utd

Manchester City manager Pep Guardiola has been accused of ‘overthinking’ his tactics following the club’s Carabao Cup semi-final second leg defeat to Manchester United.

The holders progressed to a third successive League Cup final courtesy of a 3-2 aggregate success against their Manchester rivals, though Guardiola’s side were given a scare as Nemanja Matic’s goal secured United a 1-0 victory in the second leg at the Etihad.

Guardiola chose to play with just one recognised central defender in Nicolas Otamendi for the contest in a bid to seemingly flood the midfield areas, and former Man City defender Micah Richards has accused the Spaniard of overthinking his tactics.

“For me, [City] had a good 15 minutes and then United worked them out,” Richards said in his role as a pundit for Sky Sports.

Man City’s average positions v Man Utd

“I saw Raheem [Sterling] receiving the ball in his own half. I saw Bernardo [Silva] doing the same on the opposite side. I’m thinking – why not play 4-3-3? It felt like a training game for City at times.

“The game is still 1-0, you’ve got to make changes early. I’m no manager, and I don’t want to go on about Pep’s tactics and style of play, but you’ve got Kyle Walker, who’s arguably one of the best right-backs in the league, playing as a centre half.

“You’ve got [Joao] Cancelo playing left-back. You’ve got Rodri dropping into centre-back and you’ve got this box in midfield where they’re all doing similar jobs.

“You’ve got Eric Garcia and John Stones on the bench – what does that do for their confidence?

“We’ve seen it time after time; when Pep gets it right, it’s incredible because he and Klopp are the best managers in the world. But tonight I felt he was overthinking little things he didn’t need to do.”

De Bruyne far from happy as ‘sloppy’ Man City seal Carabao Cup final place

See also – The five highest scoring Premier League players since the start of December